A New Status Anxiety is Infecting Affluent Hipdom

The always-witty Sandra Tsing Loh has a piece in the latest Atlantic Monthly titled Class Dismissed: A new status anxiety is infecting affluent hipdom. It’s a Brooksian take on how the self-styled cool and rich are signaling status. I excerpt the best grafs below.

On the new search for self-expression:

In the relatively affluent post–Cold War era, the search for self-expression has evolved into a desire to not have that self-expression challenged, which in turn necessitates living among people who think and feel just as you do. It’s why so many bohemians flee gritty Los Angeles for verdant Portland, where left-leaning citizens pride themselves on their uniform, monotonously progressive culture—the Zipcars, the organic gardens, the funky graphic-novel stores, and the thriving alternative-music scene. (In the meantime, I’ve also noticed that Portland is much whiter than Los Angeles, disconcertingly white.)

On signaling one’s degree:

Even today, I think one’s relation to one’s alma mater is fraught with haute-bourgeois peril. In descending order of coolness are:

1. Dropped out of prestigious college;

2. Graduated from prestigious school, never bring it up unless asked—then as joke;

3. Graduated from prestigious school with honors, bring up quickly, no irony;

4. Graduated, have become garish, cheerful head of alumni booster committee.

On charity and the convenience of caring about the faraway poor:

Charity itself is complicated when one hates to admit that one rules. Although old-school WASPs might tinkle their G-and-Ts while hosting an annual spring benefit for The Poor, the creative class will throw a star-studded fete to combat a politically fashionable disease, with celebs relaying anecdotes about personal frailty (as detailed in their candid new addiction memoirs). They can be rich and feel vaguely anti-establishment at the same time. The New World is all Richard Branson interviewed by Charlie Rose onstage at the Clinton Conference on Global … Whatever—with a faint chunky mix-in of Third World Poverty. (The creative class usually prefers faraway poor people to the local variety, and always prefers the “ethnic” poor to the white kind.)

Great little anecdote on San Francisco and trusting Craiglist over the police:

In 2000, the research of Robert Putnam, author of Bowling Alone, showed that the correlation between the health of civic culture and the affluence of the local economy was actually negative; the highest-tech cities tended to have the lowest rate of civic connections. I think of the Silicon Valley runner guy we met in San Francisco who, when we showed him a set of lost car keys we’d found on the path in Golden Gate Park, said: “I wouldn’t trust the police with those. Post a notice on Craigslist!”

7 Responses to A New Status Anxiety is Infecting Affluent Hipdom

  1. JU says:

    Awesome posts as usual. One quibble–there are four or five words that I think you use too much. “Graf” is one of them. Could you find a substitute? It just seems like an all-around awkward word.

  2. Sandra is amazing – and just as relentlessly witty in person, even if not performing on stage. She’s one of the most strikingly intelligent, talented, and kindhearted people I’ve ever met.

    Bonus: I cooked her dinner and she raved about it (so she must have great taste, too).

  3. Ben Casnocha says:

    Graf = paragraph and is used constantly by people in the media / journalists so I picked it up from there. Not sure there are too many replacement words for it though…. What are the other words that annoy you? :)

  4. John Maxwell says:

    (The creative class usually prefers faraway poor people to the local variety, and always prefers the “ethnic” poor to the white kind.)

    How convenient, since helping faraway poor people is so much easier.

  5. JU says:

    I just quickly glanced through your past posts, and to tell the truth I can’t think of the others. Maybe I just imagined something. Anyways, I’ll be back if I come across anything. Overall, though, your writing is great and concise/clear.

  6. Stephanie Geerlings says:

    “I wouldn’t trust the police with those. Post a notice on Craigslist!”

    Too bad I sort of agree with this. The police need online search. It’s not for lack of trust, but lack of organization.

  7. a0z0ra says:

    OMG.. this article is for people with superb reading level. I got extremely tired after reading it, and actually felt kind of lost :(

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>