How the Response to the Italy vs. U.S. Soccer Game Explains Some European/U.S. Differences

After the U.S. tied Italy in the World Cup in a bloody match that left several players with red cards (kicked out) and various injuries, the commentary fell in one of two camps: a) the Americans displayed heart and valor in the surprising effort or b) “The U.S. team makes its own publicity true and turns the game into war” in an effort that shamed the country and the sport. Roger Cohen, who writes the “Globalist” column in the International Herald Tribune, had a great analysis a few days ago (TimesSelect) about how the two reactions speak to the differences in European and American vernacular and values. He writes, “Europe lives in a post-heroic and post-militaristic culture” whereas “Wars, warriors, blood, and military bases: such images, and locations, are the stuff of everyday American life.” Indeed, the American players were housed at Ramsein Air Base prior to the match and striker Eddie Johnson said the American team is “here for a war” while the goalie Kasey Keller said the nine men left standing in the game “bled today for our country and our team.”

From advertising to the metaphors of high-school sports coaches, the message of life as a battle inseparable from valor, individual heroism, sacrifice, grand dreams and allegiance to the Stars and Stripes is often insistent. In Europe, of course, the vernacular is a very different one. It is, in general, that of a continent that saw too many of its own cut down in the 20th century to see in military heroism anything but a destructive illusion. For Europe, peace is a core value; Americans see the world another way.

Hmm. He doesn’t say “Americans see it the opposite” — which I think is accurate delicacy. It’s not as if peace isn’t a core value for America, it’s one of a few. Cohen continues,

In this age where America cannot go anywhere without stirring controversy, it was inevitable that a football game would stir some more. And the arguments have led me to ponder whether I would rather live in a heroic or post-heroic culture, whether I prefer guileless enthusiasm or sophisticated cynicism. The American quest for heros can easily turn tacky. Hero itself is an overused word…But the instinct behind the tackiness should not be scorned. Europe does scorn very well. It is a reactive power, and what it principally reacts to is the United States. Being the chief protagonist of history is more difficult; you ahve to put yourself forward and you are going to conspicuous mistakes. But I prefer the risk-taking culture that is ready to commit those errors in the name of big ideas to the one that derides the mistakes.

Naturally, Cohen concludes he thought the Italy-America game had an “elemental magnificence.” I didn’t see the game, so I can’t comment on the accuracy of the analogy, but I do I think some of the cultural contrasts work. What do you think?

3 Responses to How the Response to the Italy vs. U.S. Soccer Game Explains Some European/U.S. Differences

  1. Patrick Wendell says:

    I don’t know Ben. I’ve been to a number of soccuer games here (just big-screen broadcasts of the World Cup games) and after the game finishes, regardless of who wins, there is fighting and violence in the streets. The so-called “hooligans”, traveling gangs who associate themselves with soccer teams and rumble with one another, surely contradict such insistence on peace as a “core value” of European sports or overall culture. When Switzerland won on Friday, police had to use tear gas to control the rioting.

    So while the athletes may or may not see games as a war, a good number of fans do.

  2. Chris Yeh says:

    As far as differing opinions of war, you have to remember how different the experiences of Europe and the USA in the world wars of the 20th century were.

    The United States fought in both wars, suffered less than 500,000 killed, and the homeland was essentially untouched.

    In contrast, Germany lost over 6 million killed, on a much smaller population base, and saw their country reduced to rubble (not to mention the rape of 100,000 German women by the Soviet army).

    In other words, war was easily at least one order of magnitude more horrifying for the Europeans than the Americans. That doesn’t even count the horrific death totals of the Napoleonic Wars and all the other previous conflicts.

  3. Christian says:

    Well before they change the rules and dramatically affect the way the game is played, why don’t you go see the Final Match Live in Berlin!
    JUMPTV IS GIVING AWAY A TRIP TO THE WORLD CUP!
    JumpTV is giving away two tickets to the WORLD CUP! A winner and guest will be flown to Berlin to see the final game of the World Cup, put up in one of the finest hotels in Berlin and given $2,500.00 to spend! Details are available on: link to www2.jumptv.com.
    Want details about the company? Check out the website http://www.jumptv.com and these articles from the NY Times and Fortune Magazine: link to money.cnn.com and
    link to nytimes.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>