That’s the title of my latest book read. Alfie Kohn compiles a variety of essays on education, standards, grading, “and other follies” into a interesting book.
He starts with his most provokative essay titled the same as the book. He asks “What is purpose of education?”
Ned Noddings of Stanford urges us to reject “the deadly notion that the schools’ first priority should be intellectual development” and contends that “the main aim of education should be to produce competent, caring, loving, and lovable people.” Alternatively, we might wade into the dispute btwn those who see education as a means to creating or sustaining a democratic society and those who believe its primary role is economic, amounting to an “investment” in future works and, ultimately, corporate profits. In short, perhaps the question “How do we know if education has been successful?” shouldn’t be posed until we have asked what it’s supposed to be successful at.
He continues by discussing the qualification of an “educated person”:
How much do you have to know about neutrinos, or the Boxer rebellion, or the side-angle-side theorem? If deep understanding is required, then a) very few people could be considered well educated, and b) the number of items about which anyone could have that level of knowledge is sharply limited because time is finite. On the other hand, how can we justify a cocktail party level of familiarity with all these items – reminiscent of Woody Allen’s summary of War and Peace after taking a speed reading course: “It’s about Russia.”
Next, he cites Deborah Meier in her list of the importance of developing five “habits of mind” in schools: the value of raising questions about evidence (“How do we know what we know?”), point of view (“Whose perspective does this represent?”), connections (“How is this related to that?”), supposition (“How might things have been otherwise?”), and relevance (“Why is this important?”).
He concludes the chapter citing Dewey: To be well educated, then, is to have the desire as well as the means to make sure that learning never ends.
He then dives into a blistering critique on standarized tests, grading, the costs of overemphasizing achievement, and more. While I agree with most of his stuff, I do take exception with one assertion in the chapter “Confusing Harder with Better.” He says “No student should be expected to meet an academic requirement that a cross section of successful adults in the community cannot.” I disagree. If this were the standard, how do we achieve progress? How do we stretch our minds deeply to find out what we want to do with our lives?
If you are interested in new thinking about education or have kids in schools, check out Kohn’s work.
Thanks Ben! I requested it from my local library and can’t wait to read it. – Chris
Very interesting, Ben. I will have to add this to my list of books to read.
I often get into debates on the value of education and the manner in which education should be experienced. I have had discussions with my girlfriend (education major at Dartmouth) and a programmer here at ATX Communications.
I always seem to hear the same thing from my programming co-worker, whom by the way refuses to go to college. “Why should I have to go to schhol and learn about things I could care less about or even worse, never use in my job.”
That arguement is all well and good, but I always challenge him to realize that he may not always be a computer programmer, and that it isn’t “cool” (or whatever the vernacular is) to not know anything besides your field of study. I value my rudimentary knowledge of Shakespere and Geometry. Sure it is less than fun while you are doing it in a class setting, but when you come across a problem in real life and can solve it using what you have learned and thought you would never use, I think that is a true accomplishment. That is what I think education and being a well educated person means…It means being able to take knowledge and transform it into solutions, which in turn boosts the person’s self confidence and self-esteem.
When it comes down to it, education is all about building confident caring citizens.
Travis:
Right, for me it means becoming an *interesting* person. There are plenty of smart, capable, talented people out there (like your friend). But you can only go so far up the ladder if you know only a lot about one thing in this world and not some about a lot of things.
You still may be able to keep your options open and become interesting without college, but it would be much much harder.
P.S. Since the book is in essay form you it is easy to skip over those topics that don’t interest you and sink in deep to those that do.
Best,
Ben Casnocha
dads happen to be skeptics or possibly Deists; individuals actually made a fabulous secular governing by “unbreachable wall” approximately house of worship and additionally assert; individuals still gave them throughout the treaty along with the Moslem location about Tripoli a right announcement which usually, nothing like The european union, all the “United State governments isn’t really, in any meaning, a fabulous Stacee location. ” (So finally appreciated was first all the precept about separation about house of worship and additionally assert just of the fact that treaty went by Our lawmakers with very little discourse relating to which usually terms, and additionally Chief executive Tom Adams fixed the software instantly, with very little terror that hot weather will probably put at risk an individual’s politics long term future. )